I'll save you the suspense and put my bracket guess at the top, with the explanation to follow. So here it is by seed, I won't bother embarrassing myself by putting them in regions:
1: UNC, Ohio St, Florida, UCLA
2: Wisconsin, Georgetown, Kansas, Pitt
3: Memphis, Texas A&M, Oregon, Texas
4: Southern Illinois, Maryland, Virginia Tech, Washington St
5: Louisville, Notre Dame, Tennessee, USC
6: UNLV, Marquette, Virginia, Creighton
7: Arizona, Nevada, Villanova, Boston College
8: Duke, Butler, Vandy, Xavier
9: BYU, Indiana, Michigan St, Kentucky
10: VCU, Georgia Tech, Arkansas, ODU
11: Winthrop, Syracuse, Illinois, Purdue
12: Drexel, Davidson, GW, Gonzaga
13: Wright St, New Mexico St, Miami(OH), Holy Cross
14: Albany, Long Beach, Penn, TAMU-CC
15: Niagra, Oral Roberts, Eastern Kentucky, Belmont
16: Central Conn St, North Texas, Weber St
16b: Jackson St, FAMU
Last 5 Out: Stanford, Kansas St, Missouri St, Texas Tech, Air Force
Some Comments On Today's Games:
- Kansas can earn a 1-seed by winning the Big 12. Wisconsin can earn a 1-seed by winning the Big 10. But it's inter-related. UNC and Ohio St are locks as 1-seeds regardless of the outcome today. Florida is a lock if they win the SEC tourney. If all three win, Kansas is the team stuck with the 2-seed. If Florida loses, it loses a 1-seed before UCLA. So it's still pretty fluid.
- If NC State wins, Drexel is out of the tourney. They are my last team in. Arkansas is in even with a loss.
- Northwestern St would save the Committee the PR disaster of a play-in game between two traditionally black colleges. The Committee has bent over backwards in previous years to prevent the all-black college play-in game, but FAMU and Jackson St are clearly the two worst teams in the tourney. Northwestern St would allow them to bump Jackson St to the 16-seed line. And Niagra would get TAMU-CC's 14-seed and North Texas would move up to the 15-seed.
All right, the bubble is ridiculously close right now. I've gone back and forth all weekend. So, let me explain my logic and I'll willingly concede I'm going to miss at least two, probably four.
Every team on the top 9 seed lines are locks, and all of the teams on the 13 seed line and below are auto qualifiers plus three 12-seeds, one 11-seed, and one 10-seed (maybe two if Arkansas wins). Add that up, and that leaves only seven at-large slots and plenty of viable candidates. Here's how I separated them, in order of how they are on my personal S-Curve
GEORGIA TECH (#52, 20-11)
The road record sucks and they were slightly below 500 in ACC play, but they finished strong and they are 8-9 vs. the RPI top 50. That's just a boatload of tough games.
ARKANSAS (#35, 21-12)
They played a tough OOC schedule, and they are finally above .500 in the SEC. Their road record is mitigated by going 6-1 on neutral courts. They are 5-4 vs. the RPI top 50 (which to me is the biggest guide, did you play good teams and did you beat them?)
OLD DOMINION (#40, 24-8)
Won the CAA regular season title. 9-1 in their last 10. Beat Georgetown in Georgetown. They have three really bad losses, but they have enough huge positives to outweigh that.
SYRACUSE (#51, 21-10)
11-7 in the Big East. I think that's what does it. The conference is brutal, and they won 11 games. The other peripherals are average at best (3-7 vs. the top 50), but you win in the Big East this year, you get in.
ILLINOIS (#29, 23-11)
No bad losses. They have a high RPI. And they scheduled a brutal OOC slate, something the Committee has long sressed. They should be rewarded for not ducking anyone.
PURDUE (#42, 21-11)
I'm actually not sold. I wouldn't put them in, but I'm hedging because so many people do. Their road record stinks, they played .500 in conference, and they are 3-6 vs. the top 50. Actually, I'm changing my mind again. I'm sticking to my guns and say they don't make it, they don't have the OOC slate that Illinois did and their win over the Illini was at home.
DREXEL (#39, 22-8)
13 road wins. I'm simply flabbergasted by that. TheCommittee tells the mid-majors to go on the road and play tough. Well, that's what Drexel did. If the Committee obeys their guidelines, Drexel's in.
Hey, I have a new team to put in Purdue's slot! Let's look at the contenders:
STANFORD (#63, 18-12)
The RPI freaks me out. 4-6 in the last 10, and the Committee loves teams they are hot. 4-8 vs. the top 50. Not enough to get in.
TEXAS TECH (#53, 21-12)
They lost by 20 with their tourney lives on the line. No real positives, but no negatives either. They are just decent on the road, in conference, out of conference, and vs. the top 50. That loss just kills me. And I still only have three Big 12 teams in, all seeded three or above.
KANSAS ST (#56, 22-11)
Play a team with a pulse. 2-6 vs. the top 50, but most importantly, their OOC schedule was a joke. Their best OOC win is USC. The second best is Tennessee Tech. That doesn't cut it. The Committee has routinely punished teams for lousy schedules. They won' buck the trend to help Bob Huggins.
MISSOURI ST (#36, 21-10)
13-7 in the Valley. 8-4 on the road. 1-7 vs. tourney teams. But that one is Wisconsin. I really want to put them in, but they really do lack marquee wins.
AIR FORCE (#30, 22-8)
They played their way out of the tourney by absolutely imploding down the stretch. they actuially have a nice profile, but they are in an absolute free fall.
FLORIDA ST (#41, 20-12)
Below 500 in conference. 4-6 in the last 10. 5-9 vs. the top 50. Does that sound like a tourney team to you?
APPALACHAIN ST (#59, 22-7)
3-2 vs. the top 50, but no games against the top 25. Nine road wins, a gaudy conference record. Didn't just lose those two games, they got crushed. Clemson beat them by 30, Virginia Tech by 32. OK, they beat VCU and Vandy narrowly. I would love to put them in, but I don't think the Committee will.
Looking at that group, I am reminded why I put Purdue in the field in the first place. Also, looking at those flawed profiles reminds me why the field does not need to expand past the current 65. The teams are tightly packed, and it really is a crapshoot right now.
Showing posts with label bracketology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bracketology. Show all posts
Sunday, March 11, 2007
Monday, March 5, 2007
Bracketology: The Random Ass Guess
All things considered, the Committee does a terrific job of putting the field of 64 together. They are open about the criteria used, and more importantly, they usually stick to the criteria. Sure, I'll have my quibbles with the Committee, but very rarely will I be completely outraged by a selection or a seed (I thought they were way off on seeding Vermont two years ago, but Vermont's upset win validated my opinion). This isn't a bunch of guys slapping together the bracket in 30 minutes, handing out favors to their friends. This isn't football.
LSU is about as far from the bubble as a team can be, but since Pittman lives in Alabama and we've got Tuscaloosa on the name of this page, we'll look at the bracket selections by using the Crimson Tide as our test team. This isn't so much as to predict Bama's chances, but to give everyone an idea how the Committee evaluates who's in and who's out. Since I'm a good Maryland boy, I'll also use the Terps to demonstrate how seeding works near the top of the bracket.
I will probably take a stab at projecting seeds on Saturday, but I'm not Joe Lunardi or Jerry Palm. I can get you an idea of the field, but in the end, there's only so much time I'm willing to put into the analysis. Besides, it might be fun to see how a non-expert fares against the professionals.
THE BUBBLE: ALABAMA
Probably the most important factor is conference standings. Everything starts from there. It's a good objective measure of how a team measures against teams of relative quality, though teams often break out of the order of their conference standings. It gives us the place to start. Bama is 7-9 in the SEC, a huge strike to kick things off. Georgia, Ole Miss, and Mississippi State all finished 8-8, and Bama is tied with Arkansas and Auburn. It is also important to note the mantra: conferences don't get bids, teams do.
The RPI is then used as guide to relative quality. It's not a critical factor, but we six teams to sort through and we haven't even gotten out of the SEC. Alabama has an RPI of 43, slightly better than Arkansas' #48, but definitely in the same ballpark. Georgia and the Mississippi schools are all hovering in the lower 60s, while Auburn's #104 will doom their chances.
The Committee loves "hot" teams down the stretch. Frankly, I think this is a stupid factor, but I don't make the rules. Also, since every tourney game is a road game, there is weight given to the road record. Bama went 2-8 on the road (4-0 on neutral courts) and staggered to a 5-5 finish in their last ten. Luckily for Bama, Arkansas has been just as bad down the stretch and on the road. In fact, none of the 8-8 teams distinguish themselves here either. The best road record is Georgia's 3-9 and no team is better than 6-4 down the stretch.
So how did they do out of conference? The Committee often punishes teams for weak out-of-conference scheduling and rewards teams for playing tough games OOC. Here is where Bama shines. Bama's non-conference RPI is 15. They scheduled Xavier, Iowa, Oklahoma, and Notre Dame OOC; and while most of those teams fell flat on their face this year, it was a good effort by Bama to schedule good teams. Arkansas' non-conference RPI is 22 with wins over Southern Illinois and West Virginia, and losses to Texas, Texas Tech, and Missouri. The 8-8 teams all have weak OOC schedules, creating some separation in Bama and Arkansas' favor.
Which gets us to the last hurdle: good wins and bad losses. Bama is 2-6 vs. the RPI top 50. They have two losses to teams ranked in the 100s. Arkansas also has two bad losses, but they are 4-5 versus the RPI top 50. That SIU win is huge right now.
Looking through the factors, I'd have to put Arkansas slightly ahead of Alabama. Which means that Bama doesn't get considered against the at-large pool from other conferences until Arkansas gets in. And Arkansas' profile doesn't exactly blow you away. Alabama’s not dead, but close to it.
THE SEEDING: MARYLAND
The criteria is the same, but the big difference here is that we’ve already separated the team out of their conference hierarchy. You’re going to have to trust me, but Maryland is the #2 ACC team behind UNC. They finished in a four-way tie for second, but unlike Bama, the Terps have terrific peripherals: 6-4 on the road, 8-2 in their last 10, 4-0 vs. the RPI top 25, and a non-conference RPI of 8 to go with their #10 RPI overall.
At this point, it becomes a balancing act. For example, Pitt has a better conference record (and the Big East is of similar quality to the ACC) to go with a better overall record. Pitt has an even better road record than the Terps and a better overall RPI. About the only thing Maryland can point to is Pitt is that Pitt is 4-5 against the RPI top 50, while Maryland has just as many wins if just counting the top 25. Versus the top 50, Maryland is 9-6. They have more wins against the top 50 than Pitt has games against the top 50.
That’s simply not good enough. The interesting thing comes when it’s time to compare radically different profiles. Like Memphis. Memphis is 27-3 (16-0) and ranked 8th in the RPI. They have won all of their last 10 games and they have a killer road record. They also haven’t beaten a team with a pulse. Memphis is 1-3 vs. the RPI top 50. OK, they beat Kentucky. Their second best win? Ole Miss.
So the Committee has to sort through a Memphis team which hasn’t lost this calendar year against a Maryland team which went 10-6 in a brutal conference. Good luck. And that’s when we move beyond the “science” of Bracketology and into mere guesswork.
LSU is about as far from the bubble as a team can be, but since Pittman lives in Alabama and we've got Tuscaloosa on the name of this page, we'll look at the bracket selections by using the Crimson Tide as our test team. This isn't so much as to predict Bama's chances, but to give everyone an idea how the Committee evaluates who's in and who's out. Since I'm a good Maryland boy, I'll also use the Terps to demonstrate how seeding works near the top of the bracket.
I will probably take a stab at projecting seeds on Saturday, but I'm not Joe Lunardi or Jerry Palm. I can get you an idea of the field, but in the end, there's only so much time I'm willing to put into the analysis. Besides, it might be fun to see how a non-expert fares against the professionals.
THE BUBBLE: ALABAMA
Probably the most important factor is conference standings. Everything starts from there. It's a good objective measure of how a team measures against teams of relative quality, though teams often break out of the order of their conference standings. It gives us the place to start. Bama is 7-9 in the SEC, a huge strike to kick things off. Georgia, Ole Miss, and Mississippi State all finished 8-8, and Bama is tied with Arkansas and Auburn. It is also important to note the mantra: conferences don't get bids, teams do.
The RPI is then used as guide to relative quality. It's not a critical factor, but we six teams to sort through and we haven't even gotten out of the SEC. Alabama has an RPI of 43, slightly better than Arkansas' #48, but definitely in the same ballpark. Georgia and the Mississippi schools are all hovering in the lower 60s, while Auburn's #104 will doom their chances.
The Committee loves "hot" teams down the stretch. Frankly, I think this is a stupid factor, but I don't make the rules. Also, since every tourney game is a road game, there is weight given to the road record. Bama went 2-8 on the road (4-0 on neutral courts) and staggered to a 5-5 finish in their last ten. Luckily for Bama, Arkansas has been just as bad down the stretch and on the road. In fact, none of the 8-8 teams distinguish themselves here either. The best road record is Georgia's 3-9 and no team is better than 6-4 down the stretch.
So how did they do out of conference? The Committee often punishes teams for weak out-of-conference scheduling and rewards teams for playing tough games OOC. Here is where Bama shines. Bama's non-conference RPI is 15. They scheduled Xavier, Iowa, Oklahoma, and Notre Dame OOC; and while most of those teams fell flat on their face this year, it was a good effort by Bama to schedule good teams. Arkansas' non-conference RPI is 22 with wins over Southern Illinois and West Virginia, and losses to Texas, Texas Tech, and Missouri. The 8-8 teams all have weak OOC schedules, creating some separation in Bama and Arkansas' favor.
Which gets us to the last hurdle: good wins and bad losses. Bama is 2-6 vs. the RPI top 50. They have two losses to teams ranked in the 100s. Arkansas also has two bad losses, but they are 4-5 versus the RPI top 50. That SIU win is huge right now.
Looking through the factors, I'd have to put Arkansas slightly ahead of Alabama. Which means that Bama doesn't get considered against the at-large pool from other conferences until Arkansas gets in. And Arkansas' profile doesn't exactly blow you away. Alabama’s not dead, but close to it.
THE SEEDING: MARYLAND
The criteria is the same, but the big difference here is that we’ve already separated the team out of their conference hierarchy. You’re going to have to trust me, but Maryland is the #2 ACC team behind UNC. They finished in a four-way tie for second, but unlike Bama, the Terps have terrific peripherals: 6-4 on the road, 8-2 in their last 10, 4-0 vs. the RPI top 25, and a non-conference RPI of 8 to go with their #10 RPI overall.
At this point, it becomes a balancing act. For example, Pitt has a better conference record (and the Big East is of similar quality to the ACC) to go with a better overall record. Pitt has an even better road record than the Terps and a better overall RPI. About the only thing Maryland can point to is Pitt is that Pitt is 4-5 against the RPI top 50, while Maryland has just as many wins if just counting the top 25. Versus the top 50, Maryland is 9-6. They have more wins against the top 50 than Pitt has games against the top 50.
That’s simply not good enough. The interesting thing comes when it’s time to compare radically different profiles. Like Memphis. Memphis is 27-3 (16-0) and ranked 8th in the RPI. They have won all of their last 10 games and they have a killer road record. They also haven’t beaten a team with a pulse. Memphis is 1-3 vs. the RPI top 50. OK, they beat Kentucky. Their second best win? Ole Miss.
So the Committee has to sort through a Memphis team which hasn’t lost this calendar year against a Maryland team which went 10-6 in a brutal conference. Good luck. And that’s when we move beyond the “science” of Bracketology and into mere guesswork.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)